The best replacement for halloween is christmas.

The best alternatives to halloween are rated as following:
★★★★★  christmas
★★★★  friday the 13th
★★★  day of the dead
★★★  dia de los muertos
★★  hallowe'en
★★  williamsburg
★★  prom night
★  nightmare on elm street
★  helloween
★  thanksgiving
★  holloween
★  scream
★  all hallows eve
★  texas chainsaw massacre
★  valentine's day
★  brooklyn
★  all saints day
★  halloween
★  psycho
  bonfire night
  harvest
  day of the dead similarities
  costumes
  nightmare elm street
  hellraiser
  todos los santos
  biblia
  easter
  sf. andrei
  dia de muertos
  christians
  samhain
  friday the 13th movie
  on halloween
  el dia de los muertos

Your alternative for halloween is not listed? Suggest!
Speaking about halloween, one probably shouldn't forget about michael myers.

Other search terms related to halloween and their ratings are:
★★★★★ michael myers
★★ rolanda
★★ martha stewart
pumpkin halloween
You have in mind a companion for halloween and it is not yet here? Propose!



Google Trends

Scale is based on the average worldwide traffic of halloween in all years. Click on graph for more.
halloween
christmas
friday the 13th