The best replacement for stiff is regular shaft.

The best alternatives to stiff are rated as following:
★★★★★  regular shaft
★★★  regular flex
★★★  regular
★  regular driver
★  regular flex shaft
★  soft snowboard
★  flexible snowboard
★  soft snowboard boots
★  regular flex driver
★  regular golf shafts
★  flex shaft
★  regular shafts
★  extra stiff shaft
★  x stiff
★  regular golf shaft
★  regular shaft driver
★  soft ski boots
★  extra stiff shafts
  regular irons
  regular flex shafts
  regular driver shaft
  regular golf clubs
  not easily bent
  flex longboard
  regular shaft golf
  extra stiff
  regular clubs
  flex snowboard
  regular steel shafts
  uniflex shaft
  flex golf shaft
  reg
  flex golf clubs
  s300
  regular flex golf
  flex shafts
  soft suspension
  uniflex
  soft peaks

Your alternative for stiff is not listed? Suggest!
Speaking about stiff, one probably shouldn't forget about dean martin and jerry lewis.

Other search terms related to stiff and their ratings are:
★★★★★ dean martin and jerry lewis
You have in mind a companion for stiff and it is not yet here? Propose!



Google Trends

Scale is based on the average worldwide traffic of stiff in all years. Click on graph for more.
stiff
regular shaft
regular flex