The best replacement for rudolph is frosty.

The best alternatives to rudolph are rated as following:
★★★★★  frosty
★★★★  fleener
★★★  pettigrew
★★★  witten
★★★  finley
★★  gresham
★★  bennett
★★  olsen
★★  rudolf
★★  sarah palin
★★  pitta
★★  gates
★★  myers
★  owen daniels
★  celek
★  chandler
★  myra
★  roxanne
★  tamme
★  gronkowski
★  brent celek
★  scott chandler
★  brandon pettigrew
★  daniels
★  zach sudfeld
★  keller
★  charles clay
  sudfeld
  antonio gates
  jared cook
  greg olsen
  heath miller
  jermichael finley
  dustin keller
  snowman
  frosty the snowman
  hernandez
  fred davis
  coby fleener

Your alternative for rudolph is not listed? Suggest!
Speaking about rudolph, one probably shouldn't forget about abominable snowman.

Other search terms related to rudolph and their ratings are:
★★★★★ abominable snowman
You have in mind a companion for rudolph and it is not yet here? Propose!



Google Trends

Scale is based on the average worldwide traffic of rudolph in all years. Click on graph for more.
rudolph
frosty
fleener