The best replacement for pujols is cabrera.

The best alternatives to pujols are rated as following:
★★★★★  cabrera
★★★★  lidge
★★  alex rodriguez
★★  rodriguez
★★  cano
★★  arod
★★  ramirez
★★  hosmer
★★  jeter
★★  fielder
★  kemp
★  votto
★  beltran
★  hanley ramirez
★  brad lidge
★  bautista
★  shaq
★  miguel cabrera
★  carlos gonzalez
★  a-rod
★  babe ruth
★  dempster
★  mccutchen
★  hanley
★  miggy
  mauer
  prince fielder
  manny
  adrian gonzalez
  joe mauer
  robinson cano
  rnrh
  teixeira
  ryan howard
  derek jeter
  barry bonds
  matt kemp

Your alternative for pujols is not listed? Suggest!
Speaking about pujols, one probably shouldn't forget about cardinals.

Other search terms related to pujols and their ratings are:
★★★★★ cardinals
★ paula deen
★ st louis cardinals
You have in mind a companion for pujols and it is not yet here? Propose!



Google Trends

Scale is based on the average worldwide traffic of pujols in all years. Click on graph for more.
pujols
cabrera
lidge