The best replacement for pie is cake.

The best alternatives to pie are rated as following:
★★★★★  cake
★★★  cobbler
★★  tart
★★  no pie
★★  pumpkin pie
★  apple pie
★  bar chart
★  pi
★  shepherds pie
★  sweet potato pie
★  dutch apple pie
★  cupcakes
  buttermilk pie
  pizza
  casserole
  cake debaters
  tpa
  cottage pie
  blueberry cobbler
  cake cbc
  peach cobbler
  cake the debaters
  torte
  apple crisp
  scooter pie
  french apple pie
  shepherd\u0027s pie
  3.14
  moon pie
  fluttershy
  dutch
  blitzsafe
  pudding
  pie return of the pie
  shepherd's pie
  pinkamena

Your alternative for pie is not listed? Suggest!
Speaking about pie, one probably shouldn't forget about graham cracker crust.

Other search terms related to pie and their ratings are:
★★★★★ graham cracker crust
★★★ crumb topping
★★ sweetened condensed milk
★★ chocolate crust
★★ canned peaches
★★ vanilla pudding
★ frozen strawberries
pie
gingersnap crust
You have in mind a companion for pie and it is not yet here? Propose!



Google Trends

Scale is based on the average worldwide traffic of pie in all years. Click on graph for more.
pie
cake
cobbler