The best replacement for jelly is jam.

The best alternatives to jelly are rated as following:
★★★★★  jam
★★★★  preserves
★★  syrup
★★  jello
★★  bee pollen
★★  honey
★  jam joke
★  jam healthier
★  vaseline
★  syrup chris rock
★  quora
★  need
★  marmalade
★  butter
★  fruit spread
★  liquid lubricant
★  astroglide
★  peanut butter
  nutella
  gravy cat food
  jelly
  silicone
  jellyfish
  liquid lube
  surgilube
  ky jelly
  peanut butter first
  aquaphor
  bee propolis
  durex
  kitkat
  raw honey
  ctenophore
  strawberry jelly
  clr
  jams

Your alternative for jelly is not listed? Suggest!
Speaking about jelly, one probably shouldn't forget about corn syrup.

Other search terms related to jelly and their ratings are:
★★★★★ corn syrup
★★★★ pectin recipe
★★★ cream cheese
★★★ sure jell
★★★ longan
★★ bee pollen
★★ ginseng
★★ honey
★ powdered pectin
★ evaporated milk
★ lychee
You have in mind a companion for jelly and it is not yet here? Propose!



Google Trends

Scale is based on the average worldwide traffic of jelly in all years. Click on graph for more.
jelly
jam
preserves