The best replacement for iphone 3gs is iphone 4.

The best alternatives to iphone 3gs are rated as following:
★★★★★  iphone 4
★★★★  3g
★  4
★  ipod touch 4g
★  samsung captivate
★  iphone 3g
★  palm pre
★  blackberry bold
★  blackberry torch
★  nokia lumia 520
★  samsung galaxy ace
★  samsung galaxy s
  mytouch 4g
  samsung focus
  samsung galaxy s2
  ipod touch 4
  ipod touch 5g
  iphone 4g
  htc desire
  htc inspire
  blackberry storm 2
  lumia 520
  blackberry storm
  nokia n97
  htc aria
  blackberry 9700
  htc evo
  nokia n8
  htc wildfire s
  htc surround
  ipod touch
  blackberry bold 9700

Your alternative for iphone 3gs is not listed? Suggest!
Speaking about iphone 3gs, one probably shouldn't forget about ios 7.

Other search terms related to iphone 3gs and their ratings are:

★★★★★ ios 7
★★★★ ios 6
★★★★ sim activate
ios 5
ios 6 problems
You have in mind a companion for iphone 3gs and it is not yet here? Propose!

Google Trends

Scale is based on the average worldwide traffic of iphone 3gs in all years. Click on graph for more.
iphone 3gs
iphone 4