The best replacement for eyeliner is no eyeliner.

The best alternatives to eyeliner are rated as following:
★★★★★  no eyeliner
★★★★★  mascara
★★★★  eyeshadow first
★★★  eyeshadow
★★★  mascara first
★★★  pencil eyeliner
★★  pencil
★  eyeliner
★  lashes first
★  liquid eyeliner
★  eye pencil
★  false eyelashes first
★  black
★  liquid
  mascara better
  mascara on first
  fake eyelashes first
  black eyeliner
  shadow first
  regular eyeliner
  kohl
  mascara mascara
  gel eyeliner
  mac gel eyeliner
  false lashes first
  gel
  cream eyeliner
  dior eyeliner

Your alternative for eyeliner is not listed? Suggest!
Speaking about eyeliner, one probably shouldn't forget about eyeshadow.

Other search terms related to eyeliner and their ratings are:
★★★★★ eyeshadow
★★★★ mascara
★ wing
★ eyeliner
brown eyes
makeup
eyelash extensions
waterline
blue eyes
no mascara
raccoon eyes
no eyeshadow
You have in mind a companion for eyeliner and it is not yet here? Propose!



Google Trends

Scale is based on the average worldwide traffic of eyeliner in all years. Click on graph for more.
eyeliner
no eyeliner
mascara