The best replacement for elf is dwarf.

The best alternatives to elf are rated as following:
★★★★★  dwarf
★★★★  nyx
★★★  elves
★★★  fairy
★★  bare minerals
★★  night elf
★★  nars
★★  elve
★★  coastal scents
★★  undead rogue
★★  coff
★  undead
★  human mabinogi
★  pe
★  dwarf rune keeper
★  dark elf
★  pixie
★  nyx cosmetics
★  nyx setting spray
★  blood elf
★  sephora
★  leprechaun
★  orc
★  tauren druid
★  gnome
★  draenei
★  goblin
★  worgen druid
★  undead priest
★  coastal scents brushes
★  human dragon age
★  real techniques
★  troll
★  bh cosmetics
  tauren paladin
  mac brushes
  high elf
  breton
  sigma brushes
  alf
  sprite
  garmin glo
  sonia kashuk brushes
  drow
  dwarf hunter
  elf on the shelf
  elfin
  elf
  human rogue
  cassiopeia
  ultimate gps
  human runes of magic
  undead warlock

Your alternative for elf is not listed? Suggest!
Speaking about elf, one probably shouldn't forget about dio.

Other search terms related to elf and their ratings are:
★★★★★ dio
★★ ronnie james dio
You have in mind a companion for elf and it is not yet here? Propose!



Google Trends

Scale is based on the average worldwide traffic of elf in all years. Click on graph for more.
elf
dwarf
nyx