The best replacement for 2k11 is 2k12.

The best alternatives to 2k11 are rated as following:
★★★★★  2k12
★★★★★  2k13
★★★  2k12 my player
★★★  2k12 nba
★★★  2k14
★★  elite 11
★★  nba elite 11
★★  show 11
★★  nhl 11
★★  2k10
★★  mlb the show
★★  mlb the show 11
★★  nba live 11
★★  nba live
★  nba 2k13
★  mlb 2k12
★  nba 2k12
★  mlb 11 the show
★  nba live 10
★  nba live 2011
★  nba 2k12 my player
★  nba 11
★  2k12 graphics
★  elite
  madden 11
  nba elite
  mlb 2k10
  mlb 2k13
  black ops
  mlb the show 2011
  2k9
  slapshot
  nhl slapshot
  fifa 11
  nba 2k10
  live 11

Your alternative for 2k11 is not listed? Suggest!
Speaking about 2k11, one probably shouldn't forget about playstation move.

Other search terms related to 2k11 and their ratings are:
★★★★★ playstation move
★★ ps3 move
You have in mind a companion for 2k11 and it is not yet here? Propose!



Google Trends

Scale is based on the average worldwide traffic of 2k11 in all years. Click on graph for more.
2k11
2k12
2k13