The best replacement for red dead redemption is gta 4.

The best alternatives to red dead redemption are rated as following:
★★★★★  gta 4
★★★  gun
★★★  undead nightmare
★★★  skyrim
★★  gta 5
★★  la noire
★★  gta
★★  far cry 3
★  call of juarez
★  mass effect 2
★  fallout new vegas
★  alan wake
★  gta iv
★  max payne 3
★  just cause 2
★  grand theft auto 5
★  undead nightmare which is better
★  last of us
★  uncharted 2
  grand theft auto 4
  game of the year edition
  gta v
  uncharted
  modern warfare 2
  assassin's creed brotherhood
  assassin's creed 3
  assassins creed
  borderlands 2
  grand theft auto
  sleeping dogs
  borderlands
  skate 3
  call of duty black ops
  mafia 2
  halo reach
  red dead revolver
  fallout 3
  red dead redemption undead nightmare
  batman arkham city
  uncharted 3
  dead rising 2
  arkham city
  super mario galaxy 2

Your alternative for red dead redemption is not listed? Suggest!
Speaking about red dead redemption, one probably shouldn't forget about undead nightmare.

Other search terms related to red dead redemption and their ratings are:
★★★★★ undead nightmare
You have in mind a companion for red dead redemption and it is not yet here? Propose!



Google Trends

Scale is based on the average worldwide traffic of red dead redemption in all years. Click on graph for more.
red dead redemption
gta 4
gun