The best replacement for lifeproof is otterbox.

The best alternatives to lifeproof are rated as following:
★★★★★  otterbox
★★★★  otterbox armor
★★  otterbox defender
★★  otterbox iphone 5
★★  otterbox for ipad
★★  otterbox ipad
★  griffin survivor
★  survivor
★  otterbox armor iphone 5
★  preserver
★  obex
★  armor series
★  speck
★  otterbox s4
★  seidio
★  otterbox waterproof
★  mophie
★  otterbox reviews
★  survivor catalyst
★  spigen
★  defender
★  otterbox commuter
★  nuud
  otter
  armor
  ballistic
  lifeproof
  otterbox preserver
  otterbox case
  lunatik
  otterbox armor for iphone 5
  otterbox defender iphone 5s
  ballistic hc
  atlas
  otterbox iphone 4s
  otter box

Your alternative for lifeproof is not listed? Suggest!
Speaking about lifeproof, one probably shouldn't forget about zagg.

Other search terms related to lifeproof and their ratings are:
★★★★★ zagg
★★★★ fingerprint scanner
★★★ screen protector
★ invisible shield
You have in mind a companion for lifeproof and it is not yet here? Propose!



Google Trends

Scale is based on the average worldwide traffic of lifeproof in all years. Click on graph for more.
lifeproof
otterbox
otterbox armor