The best replacement for gimp is photoshop.

The best alternatives to gimp are rated as following:
★★★★★  photoshop
★★★★  paint.net
★★★  gimpshop
★★  adobe photoshop
★★  inkscape
★★  photofiltre
★★  artweaver
★  photoshop elements
★  picasa
★  illustrator
★  paint tool sai
★  lightroom
★  krita
★  sai
  adobe
  seashore
  photoshop cs6
  paint shop pro
  pixelmator
  pixlr
  photoscape
  elements
  fireworks
  photoshop cs5
  picnik
  paint
  cs3
  mypaint
  photoshop cs
  cs6
  lanyard
  boondoggle
  adobe elements
  irfan view
  irfanview
  photoshop cs4
  rawtherapee
  firealpaca
  photoshop brushes
  corel draw
  photoplus

Your alternative for gimp is not listed? Suggest!
Speaking about gimp, one probably shouldn't forget about gap.

Other search terms related to gimp and their ratings are:
★★★★★ gap
★★★ bamboo tablet
★★★ plugins
★★★ photoshop
★★ wacom tablet
★★ imvu
★★ raw files
★ gimpshop
★ wacom bamboo
★ wacom
★ lightroom
★ raw
★ photoshop gui
★ animation
★ bamboo
ghostscript
making floating layer
You have in mind a companion for gimp and it is not yet here? Propose!



Google Trends

Scale is based on the average worldwide traffic of gimp in all years. Click on graph for more.
gimp
photoshop
paint.net